Do Quasars and Their Starbursts Grow Together? ALMA Data Suggest Only Loosely

A quasar that also blazes in the infrared

Some quasars are not just brilliant beacons from a feeding supermassive black hole. They also blaze in far-infrared light, where cool dust heated by newborn stars glows. A new ALMA survey has examined 142 of these far-infrared-bright quasars in the Stripe 82 region of the sky, at redshifts between 1 and 4. Redshift is a measure of cosmic expansion and distance: these objects sent their light toward us when the universe was much younger than it is today.

The study, posted as a preprint on arXiv, asks a straightforward question with a surprisingly messy answer: when a supermassive black hole is growing rapidly, are the galaxy's stars growing rapidly too?

ALMA sharpens the star formation rates

The quasars were first flagged by the Herschel Space Observatory's SPIRE instrument, which saw them glowing in the far infrared. But SPIRE's beam was broad, roughly 18 to 36 arcseconds across. That is large enough for several galaxies to fall into a single measurement. If more than one dusty object contributed to the light, earlier estimates of star formation could be too high.

To untangle that, the team used the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array, or ALMA. ALMA Band 7 observed at 870 micrometers with a resolution of about 0.8 arcseconds, sharp enough to separate individual dusty sources within the fuzzy Herschel beam. For 65 percent of the quasars, ALMA found a single submillimeter counterpart. The remaining 35 percent had multiple counterparts within the SPIRE beam, meaning their far-infrared glow was blended.

With the ALMA data added to each quasar's spectral energy distribution, a measurement of how its brightness varies across wavelengths, the revised star formation rates fell. For quasars with a single submillimeter counterpart, the estimates dropped by about 20 percent. For blended, multi-component systems, they dropped by more than a factor of two, sometimes much more. The uncertainties also shrank, by roughly 17 percent for total infrared luminosity and 18 percent for star formation rate.

The downward revision did not make these objects ordinary. The newly derived star formation rates range from 500 to 3,000 solar masses per year, with a median of 1,080. The authors describe these as extreme starbursts, even after the blur is removed.

An independent radio clue supports the starburst picture. Using 1.4 GHz observations from the Very Large Array, the researchers found that these far-infrared-bright quasars have a detection fraction about three times that reported for the general Sloan Digital Sky Survey DR7 quasar population. Most of the stronger (5-sigma) radio detections fall along the well-known far-infrared-radio correlation, a relationship in star-forming galaxies where dust heated by young stars and radio emission from supernova remnants rise together. That suggests the radio and infrared emission are powered mainly by star formation, not by the quasar itself.

The black hole and the baby stars are not in lockstep

The team then compared each quasar's starburst luminosity with its accretion luminosity, a proxy for how fast the central black hole is feeding. If star formation and black hole growth were tightly coupled, the two should rise and fall together.

They do not, at least not strongly. The best-fitting relation has a shallow slope of 0.12 plus or minus 0.06. A tenfold increase in accretion luminosity corresponds to only about a 30 percent increase in starburst luminosity. The statistical preference for even that weak trend is modest, about two sigma. And the intrinsic scatter is larger: at any given accretion rate, host galaxies span a wide range of star formation rates. On the timescales probed here, the black hole and the stellar nursery are not marching in step.

A brief transition between dusty blowout and blue quasar

The team also compared stacked optical spectra of the far-infrared-bright quasars with a matched sample of far-infrared-faint quasars. The bright objects show weaker Lyman-alpha and C IV emission lines, while Mg II and the ultraviolet-optical continuum remain similar. High-ionization lines like C IV are sensitive to fast-moving gas, so the pattern is consistent with quasar-driven winds affecting the fast-moving gas near the black hole. Lyman-alpha may also be suppressed by lingering neutral hydrogen. Mg II, which traces cooler and denser gas, appears relatively untouched.

Putting the pieces together, the authors suggest these rare quasars occupy a short transitional phase. They may bridge heavily obscured blowout galaxies, where dust hides the growing black hole, and unobscured blue quasars, where the dusty shroud has cleared. In this window, the host galaxy is still gas-rich and building its central bulge, while the black hole is near its peak growth rate. The rarity of far-infrared-bright quasars, only a few percent of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey quasar population, fits a brief phase. The sample also includes both isolated systems and multiple ALMA counterparts that could be nearby companions; the authors argue that no single trigger, such as a merger, is required.

What the picture still does not prove

The result comes with caveats. The paper is a preprint and has not completed peer review. For the 35 percent of quasars with multiple ALMA counterparts, the team had to redistribute the broader Herschel flux among them. That assumes the counterparts have similar dust properties and spectral shapes across the SPIRE wavelengths, but their redshifts are unknown. ALMA also constrains the long-wavelength tail of the dust emission rather than its peak, so some uncertainty remains in the total infrared luminosity. And the weak correlation between accretion and star formation is only about two sigma, not a settled detection.

A rare moment when galaxies and black holes grow together

Even with those uncertainties, the survey changes the picture. Far-infrared-bright quasars are not simply a case of a black hole and its host growing in perfect tandem, regulated by a simple feedback loop. They look more like messy, short-lived systems where gas is still abundant enough to feed both a brilliant quasar and a violent burst of star birth. ALMA's sharp view has not made these objects less extreme. It has made their brief, crowded adolescence easier to see.