SKA and ALMA Could Watch Young Stars Flare in Real Time

Inside the Orion BN/KL region, a deeply embedded young stellar object called ORBS once lit up in radio waves. At 22 GHz, it produced a major flare. At 100 GHz, it was not detected in an integrated image with 9.3 hours of on-source time, yet time-sliced imaging caught a millimeter flare that lasted only about 10 minutes. That disappearing act hints at why star-formation astronomers want to watch the same young star at many radio wavelengths at once. A new preprint by Jan Forbrich and colleagues argues that the SKA telescopes and ALMA, both in the Southern Hemisphere, will make that kind of simultaneous watching possible, beginning with SKA Early Science.

Flares in Stereo: ORBS and the Time-Domain Window

ALMA observes across ten bands from about 35 to 950 GHz. SKA-Low covers 50-350 MHz, and SKA-Mid covers 350 MHz-15.4 GHz. SKA Early Science is planned to use 307 SKA-Low stations and 144 SKA-Mid dishes; the full design baseline calls for 512 and 197. The ALMA2030 Wideband Sensitivity Upgrade will quadruple ALMA's instantaneous bandwidth from the current 8 GHz per polarization, improving sensitivity primarily in continuum but also in spectral line observations.

Young stars are variable. Material falling onto them can drive accretion bursts, while magnetic fields can produce flares. At radio-to-submillimeter wavelengths, several processes can produce continuum emission: nonthermal radiation from energetic electrons interacting with magnetic fields, free-free emission from ionized gas, thermal glow from dust, and spinning dust. Separating them requires measuring how brightness changes across frequencies, the spectral index. Simultaneous centimeter and millimeter observations would let astronomers build spectral-index time series, a bit like a poor man's version of solar radio dynamic spectra. Existing VLA and ALMA campaigns can do some of this, but the review says the SKA telescopes and ALMA, both in the same hemisphere, will be considerably more powerful.

The catch: simultaneous visibility is limited by the longitude difference between the sites, and matching beam sizes between SKA-Mid and ALMA array configurations may be rare. SKA-Low's roughly 5-arcsecond beam will limit stellar work to very nearby sources without confusion by background sources. Predictable variable targets, not blind wide-area searches, are the best fit.

One Molecule, Five Orders of Magnitude, and Dust That Hides Chemistry

For gas between stars, the review highlights formaldehyde. At centimeter wavelengths, SKA-Mid can see formaldehyde in absorption against bright background sources, tracing gas even at low volume densities. ALMA sees formaldehyde emission lines at millimeter wavelengths, tracing warmer, denser gas. Combined, the same molecule could map density across up to five orders of magnitude, linking cloud-scale conditions to the localized cores where stars form.

ALMA is excellent at detecting interstellar complex organic molecules in warm, dense gas around young stars. SKA-Mid Band 5 would complement that by detecting long carbon chains and rings, and metal-bearing species, whose low-frequency transitions are not accessible with ALMA. More importantly, dust in the inner regions of protostellar disks can be optically thick at ALMA wavelengths, blocking molecular emission and leading to incorrect estimates of gas temperature and column density. In the protostellar binary NGC1333 IRAS 4A, for example, dust optical depth was greater than or about 1.6 at 143 GHz, enough to attenuate a methanol line by a factor of about five or more; at 250 GHz it was greater than or about 4.9, and larger at higher frequencies. At around 25 GHz, dust can be optically thin, although not for all sources. SKA-Mid's lower frequencies would reveal molecules still hidden from ALMA and help correct temperature and column-density measurements. The combination would also help remove free-free contamination, roughly 20 percent of the flux at 90 GHz in some sources, or more for high-mass young stellar objects, from studies of dust growth.

Recombination Lines, Masers, and the 15-35 GHz Gap

Radio recombination lines trace ionized gas. ALMA can observe high-frequency lines from dense ionized gas, such as H30-alpha at 231 GHz. SKA-Mid can observe many low-frequency lines from more diffuse ionized gas, which is almost unaffected by dust extinction. The review notes that SKA-Mid could simultaneously observe 82 hydrogen Hn-alpha lines in Band 1, 36 in Band 2, and 21 in Band 5a; with sufficient sensitivity, similar numbers of other lines such as Hn-beta, Hn-gamma, He n-alpha, and C n-alpha could be observed at the same time. Together, these lines would help locate H II regions embedded in extended ionized gas, measure electron temperatures, and subtract free-free contamination from dust measurements.

Masers are naturally amplified radio emission from molecules such as methanol, water, and hydroxyl. Different maser transitions trace outflows, jets, disks, and evolved H II regions. SKA-Mid's sensitivity and wide field could catch sudden maser flares during accretion bursts, and ALMA could follow up with high-frequency, high-excitation maser lines. The review points to the accretion burst in the high-mass protostar G358.93-0.03, where new methanol maser lines were reported in 2019 at both centimeter and submillimeter wavelengths. Coordinated monitoring of many transitions could constrain gas density, temperature, molecular abundance, and radiation fields around forming stars.

One practical limitation stands out. SKA-Mid Band 5 reaches up to 15 GHz, while ALMA Band 1 starts at about 35 GHz. That leaves a gap where key diagnostics, including ammonia and bright methanol lines, are hard to observe at the needed sensitivity. The review calls for a proposed SKA-Mid Band 6 covering 15-50 GHz. At present, the VLA is the only interferometer capable of covering that range, but it is restricted to the northern sky and already used at the maximum of its capabilities. Building Band 6 would extend those capabilities to the south, but it is a proposal, not an existing capability.

The paper is a forward-looking review, not a new observational result. It lays out what should become possible as SKA Early Science and the ALMA2030 upgrade come online. The paper states that SKA-Mid early science operations in 2031 will coincide with increasing availability of new ALMA capabilities. Simultaneous observations will be constrained by limited hours of joint visibility, by the need to match angular resolution, and by sensitivity and field-of-view trade-offs. The science cases rely on capabilities that are still being built or proposed. Still, the direction is clear: the southern sky is set to gain a radio counterpart to ALMA's millimeter view.

For star formation, the payoff would be a more complete time-domain picture of young stars. One observatory catches flares, another traces chemistry; one sees through dust, the other sees the dust itself. By watching the same young stars across the radio spectrum, astronomers hope to connect magnetic activity, accretion, outflows, and the chemistry that may be delivered to asteroids and comets or incorporated into planetary systems.