The Solar System Has No Current Hydrodynamic Escape. Hubble Is Key to Finding It in Alien Worlds

Some planets are not merely losing a little air. They are bleeding it. The process is called hydrodynamic escape: a host star's high-energy radiation heats a planet's upper atmosphere until gas flows away as a collisional fluid outflow. In our Solar System, no planetary body currently experiences hydrodynamic escape. Venus, Earth, and Mars may have experienced it early in their histories, but today the phenomenon is absent. That leaves exoplanets as the only available laboratory.

A white paper posted to arXiv now argues that the Hubble Space Telescope's ultraviolet capabilities are essential to that laboratory. The paper is a response to a call from the Space Telescope Science Institute for white papers on building a roadmap for Hubble science into the 2030s. It is not a new observational result; it is a synthesis of what scientists know and what they need next.

Why Hubble's ultraviolet eyes matter

Astronomers detect escaping atmospheres by watching a planet transit, or cross the face of its star. During the transit, starlight filters through the planet's extended upper atmosphere. Atoms and ions absorb specific wavelengths, leaving a fingerprint in the spectrum. In the ultraviolet, Hubble's Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph (STIS) and Cosmic Origins Spectrograph (COS) can spot hydrogen in Lyman-alpha, plus lines from carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, silicon, magnesium, and iron.

Ground-based telescopes cannot see these vacuum-ultraviolet wavelengths because Earth's atmosphere absorbs them. Hubble's UV vision is therefore a unique window. The paper notes that Hubble remains the only operating observatory capable of obtaining moderate- and high-resolution UV spectroscopy of nearby exoplanet host stars before the Habitable Worlds Observatory (HWO) begins operations.

Two gaps in the exoplanet family album

Atmospheric escape may help explain two broad patterns in the exoplanet population. The first is the hot-Neptune desert: a relative shortage of short-period, Neptune-size planets. The second is the radius gap, a dip near 1.8 Earth radii that separates smaller super-Earths from larger mini-Neptunes, which are thought to retain hydrogen and helium envelopes. Both features have been linked to atmospheric loss, but neither is fully explained by it. Recent observational work suggests the upper edge of the hot-Neptune desert is stable against photoevaporation, and the radius gap may arise from photoevaporation, core-powered mass loss, or the planet-formation process itself. The role of escape in shaping small planets remains poorly constrained.

The missing number: photoevaporation efficiency

One key quantity is photoevaporation efficiency: the ratio of gravitational energy gained by escaping gas to the ionizing energy deposited by the host star. Simulations predict that planets with deeper gravitational wells tend to have lower efficiencies, and that composition may matter too. But scientists have not yet measured this parameter accurately for a sample of planets.

Measuring it requires knowing how much high-energy radiation a star emits. The photons that drive photoevaporation have wavelengths shorter than 911 angstroms, in the extreme ultraviolet. Most stars lack direct EUV measurements because interstellar gas absorbs that light and no sensitive EUV observatory is currently operating. Astronomers reconstruct the EUV spectrum from X-ray and UV observations. Hubble's UV lines, such as Lyman-alpha, magnesium, carbon, silicon, and oxygen, trace the stellar chromosphere and transition region, while iron lines trace the corona. Without these measurements, atmospheric escape efficiencies and photochemical models remain poorly constrained.

Young planets and chemical feedback

Models predict that young sub-Jovian planets should lose mass faster in their first 100 million to 1 billion years. They are still inflated from formation, and their host stars are more active. The Gaia mission and NASA's TESS survey have helped find more young transiting planets, giving Hubble new targets. But young stars are also more variable, which complicates transit observations.

There is another twist: as a planet loses hydrogen and helium, its remaining atmosphere can become richer in heavier elements. That increase in mean molecular weight and increased thermospheric cooling can slow further escape. Some sub-Jovian planets may therefore be more resilient than pure hydrogen-helium models predict. Testing that idea will require more observations of escaping hydrogen, helium, and metals, as well as knowledge of the compositions of their upper atmospheres.

Hubble as a scout for the Habitable Worlds Observatory

HWO is designed to detect Earth-like exoplanets by direct imaging and spectroscopy and to study transiting systems. To interpret those worlds, astronomers will need to model how their atmospheres evolved under their stars' high-energy radiation. That makes Hubble data a planning tool as well as a discovery machine. In one HWO target sample of 164 stars, only 33 have reliable space-based UV measurements.

Hubble has already begun its first survey-scale program focused on atmospheric escape: the Survey of Transiting Exoplanets in Lyman-alpha, or STEL-alpha. It maps hydrogen loss across the exoplanet population using Lyman-alpha transits. The white paper recommends following it with surveys that broaden coverage in time, wavelength, and targets. It also urges monitoring stellar high-energy variations over years, sampling stellar variability on the roughly eight-hour timescale of a typical transit, and obtaining accurate out-of-transit baselines. Some planetary outflows can produce signals many hours outside transit, so observations that sample only near the optical transit may miss the true baseline.

The paper also suggests revisiting Hubble's bright-object protection policy for M dwarfs using the large database of UV flare observations, which could safely open more transit targets. And it calls for standardized metadata, such as stellar activity indices, to accompany Hubble products.

A roadmap, not a solved problem

This is a roadmap document, not a claim that Hubble has solved atmospheric escape. Many of its arguments rest on simulations, model-dependent mass-loss rates, and proxy spectra for stellar EUV emission. Direct UV detections of escape remain scarce for small planets, and stellar activity can vary during transits, complicating the signal. Hubble's future into the 2030s is still being planned. The paper's case is that losing its UV capabilities would leave a blind spot just as the search for habitable worlds accelerates.

The question is not only what Hubble has already seen. It is what its ultraviolet vision can still add. If we want to know which planets keep their atmospheres and which lose them, we need to watch the escape while it happens.