LHS 3844 b: A Dark, Featureless Rock With No Sign of Accumulated Volcanic Gases

Every 11 hours, the planet LHS 3844 b laps its small red star. It is about 1.3 times Earth's size and hot enough—roughly 805 K at equilibrium—that its dayside should glow in the infrared. When it slips behind its star, that glow vanishes from view for about half an hour. In that brief disappearance, astronomers can isolate the planet's own heat and ask a deceptively simple question: what is its surface made of?

In a preprint posted on arXiv, a team led by Sebastian Zieba of the Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian reports a James Webb Space Telescope spectrum of LHS 3844 b from 5 to 12 micrometers. That range is mid-infrared light, where rocky materials radiate heat and can reveal their composition. The answer is not a pale, Earth-like surface. It is dark, low in silica, and almost featureless.

A dip in starlight as a planetary fingerprint

LHS 3844 b is an ultra-short-period planet, orbiting its M5 host star—a small, cool red dwarf—in only about 11 hours. Previous Spitzer observations suggested it may be airless, with no thick atmosphere to move heat around. If so, its dayside is bare rock exposed to intense starlight.

The team observed three secondary eclipses with JWST's Mid-Infrared Instrument, or MIRI, using its Low Resolution Spectrometer. A secondary eclipse occurs when a planet passes behind its star. The total light from the star-plus-planet system dips slightly because the planet's dayside emission is blocked. Across the full 5-12 micrometer band, the measured eclipse depth was 696 ± 18 parts per million—about a 0.07% dip and a 39-sigma detection, meaning the signal is far stronger than random noise.

That depth corresponds to a brightness temperature of about 985 K—the temperature a blackbody would need to emit the same amount of infrared light. Combined with Spitzer data, the spectrum fits a blackbody of about 1000 K with no obvious spectral features. The planet's Bond albedo—the fraction of starlight it reflects—comes out to roughly 0.14, similar to the Moon and Mercury, assuming no heat redistribution, though with large uncertainties. It is a dark world.

But the spectrum's lack of features is itself informative. Silicate rocks show diagnostic bumps and dips in the mid-infrared, especially a silicon-oxygen stretching feature between 8 and 12 micrometers. Different silica contents, grain sizes, and textures change the shape and strength of those features.

Dark rock, not fresh powder

The team compared the planet's emission spectrum with a new library of rock spectra spanning ultramafic, mafic, and felsic compositions—categories that correspond to increasing amounts of silica—and three surface textures: solid slabs, coarsely crushed material, and fine powders.

The best match is a dark, low-silica surface, such as basalt or other olivine-rich rock. An olivine clinopyroxenite sample fits at about the 1-sigma level, and a basaltic sample from the 1919 Kilauea eruption fits at about 1.5 sigma; lower sigma means better agreement. A light-colored granite, by contrast, is disfavored at about 8.9 sigma. Granite on Earth is tied to water-driven geology, and the data show no sign of such a surface on this hot, bare planet.

Fresh powders are also a poor fit. Fine-grained powders reflect more light and produce cooler emission than the observations show. All powdered surfaces except hematite are ruled out at more than 3 sigma. That is odd for an airless planet, where impacts and solar wind should eventually pulverize rock into regolith—a broken, powdery surface layer.

One leading explanation is space weathering. On the Moon and Mercury, tiny iron particles created by micrometeorite impacts and solar-wind irradiation darken the surface. The paper finds that adding nanophase iron to powdered rock can lower its reflectivity and bring it into agreement with the JWST data. Even extreme weathering cannot rescue granite, but it can make a basalt-like powder look dark enough.

No detectable volcanic exhalations

The spectrum also constrains any gas clinging to the planet. The team used a radiative-convective equilibrium model—one that balances heating and cooling—to simulate thin atmospheres, focusing on sulfur dioxide, a gas that is easy to detect and often linked to volcanism. They tested SO2 mixed with either carbon dioxide or oxygen backgrounds.

The data rule out a CO2-dominated atmosphere with a surface pressure of 100 millibars or more at 5 sigma. They also rule out SO2 partial pressures (the share of pressure from SO2) of 10 microbars or more at 3 sigma. Venus-like concentrations of SO2 are excluded at more than 12 sigma. The result points to an old, space-weathered surface with no evidence of accumulated volcanic gases.

There are caveats. The atmospheric models assume no clouds and radiative-convective equilibrium, so unusual temperature structures or aerosols could change the predicted spectral features. The phase coverage was limited, so the team could not independently measure the phase-curve amplitude; they fixed it to the eclipse depth based on earlier Spitzer data. And the spectral uncertainties grow longward of 10 micrometers, where tentative hints of a silicate feature appear; the authors caution that the dip near 11 micrometers could be a statistical coincidence.

A bare rock with two histories

Taken together, the data allow two broad stories. LHS 3844 b could be an old, rough, space-weathered surface, darkened by iron nanoparticles much like the Moon. Or it could be a relatively fresh slab of rock, not yet pulverized by impacts. That second option would imply ongoing geologic activity—yet the spectrum shows no CO2 or SO2, the gases expected from volcanism. The authors note that outgassed gases could still collapse into cold traps—cold regions where gases condense and stay—on the planet's nightside.

Future JWST observations should help. One program, GO 7953, will collect eight more MIRI/LRS eclipses and a NIRSpec G395H eclipse to test whether the tentative silicon-oxygen feature is real. Another, GO 4008, was recently observed; it is designed to measure the planet's thermal phase curve, looking for beaming effects—infrared emission that depends on surface roughness and viewing angle—that can distinguish a smooth young surface from a rough old one.

For now, LHS 3844 b stands as a strange portrait: a rocky world darker than fresh powder, low in silica, and quiet in the gases that would betray active volcanism. It is not a small Earth. It is something more like a bare, low-silica rock—possibly an old, space-weathered relic—and a preview of how JWST will read the geology of planets beyond the solar system.