Why Are the Most Common Asteroids Missing from Our Meteorite Collections?

In June 2010, a small capsule parachuted into the Australian desert. Inside, protected from terrestrial contamination, were more than 1,500 microscopic grains from asteroid Itokawa. A decade later, Hayabusa2 delivered 5.4 grams of asteroid Ryugu. In 2023, OSIRIS-REx brought back 121.6 grams of Bennu—the largest asteroid sample yet. A review now published in Contemporary Physics and available on arXiv traces what these three deliveries have taught us about the Solar System's first solids and Earth's supply of water and organics.

Meteorites arrive without a return address

Meteorites have long been our main samples of asteroids. But they arrive without a return address. They fall through a violent atmosphere that can vaporize fragile material. Even quickly recovered meteorites react with Earth's moisture and oxygen. So meteorites are valuable but biased: they favor tough rocks and lose their geological context.

Ground telescopes, meanwhile, see asteroids as points of light. They can measure brightness and color, but not directly connect a spectrum to a specific rock type. Sample return closes that gap. Spacecraft observe the asteroid up close, then a capsule brings material to laboratories where scientists can measure elements, isotopes, minerals, and organic molecules with far greater precision.

Itokawa: a rubble pile that matched LL chondrites

Hayabusa's target Itokawa was an S-type asteroid, a common class in the inner asteroid belt. Its returned grains were olivine, pyroxene, plagioclase, and troilite—minerals that closely match LL ordinary chondrites. That confirmed a long-suspected link between S-type asteroids and LL ordinary chondrites.

But Itokawa was not a solid block. Its bulk density is 1.9 grams per cubic centimeter, while its grains have a density of 3.4. The difference implies about 40 percent empty space. Itokawa is a rubble pile: fragments of a larger, heated parent body that broke apart and re-accumulated. The mission also found the first direct evidence of space weathering—surface alteration by solar wind and micrometeorites—on an asteroid. Solar wind ions darken and redden the surface, explaining why S-type asteroids look different from the meteorites they produce.

Ryugu and Bennu: common carbonaceous asteroids, rare CI meteorites

Hayabusa2's Ryugu and OSIRIS-REx's Bennu are carbonaceous asteroids. Both are also rubble piles, and both are highly porous. Bennu's bulk density is about 1.19 grams per cubic centimeter against a grain density near 1.79—roughly half empty space.

The bigger surprise came in the lab. Ryugu and Bennu samples closely match CI chondrites, the rarest carbonaceous meteorites. Only about ten CI chondrites are known among more than 77,000 registered meteorites. Yet C-type asteroids dominate the asteroid population, making up more than 75 percent of known asteroids. The likely explanation: CI-like material is fragile and porous, so most of it breaks apart during atmospheric entry. Meteorite collections are therefore missing a large fraction of the most primitive material.

The samples also revealed how remote sensing can mislead. Ryugu's surface looked dry to spacecraft instruments, but the returned grains were rich in hydrated minerals. A thin, space-weathered skin had dehydrated the top layer, hiding a wetter interior. Bennu, by contrast, showed hydrated minerals from orbit and in the sample. Its grains contained salts—phosphates, carbonates, sulphates, chlorides—that point to ancient brines, concentrated salty liquid water that evaporated as the parent body lost its water. Ammonia levels in Bennu were far higher than in Ryugu—75 times higher—suggesting its parent formed in a colder, more distant region.

Water, organics, and a racemic supply

The carbonaceous samples are rich in organic molecules. Ryugu yielded more than 20,000 distinct organic compounds, about 20 amino acids, and all five nucleobases used in RNA and DNA. Bennu yielded 16,000 molecular formulae and 33 amino acids, including 14 of the 20 standard protein-building amino acids. This does not prove that life came from asteroids. But it does suggest that the raw ingredients for biology can form in early planetesimals and be delivered to young planets.

One result stands out. Chiral amino acids—mirror-image left- and right-handed versions—appear in roughly equal amounts in both Ryugu and Bennu. Life on Earth uses left-handed amino acids. The new samples suggest that this bias did not originate in a biased extraterrestrial supply, at least for these asteroids; the reason for the left-handed preference remains unresolved.

What the samples still cannot settle—and more capsules to come

Each sample represents a small patch of a single asteroid. Ryugu's two touchdown sites were similar, but one asteroid is not the whole population. The histories are also complex. Ryugu and Bennu may have formed from the same disrupted parent body, or from two different bodies with similar compositions; the evidence is still debated. Space weathering on the two asteroids even works in opposite spectral directions, reddening Ryugu while bluing Bennu, and the full sequence is not yet understood.

The planetary-defence angle is more constrained but still probabilistic. OSIRIS-REx refined the Yarkovsky effect—the tiny thermal recoil that nudges an asteroid's orbit—for Bennu. That work puts the cumulative impact probability through 2300 at about 1 in 1750. Bennu is not a near-term threat, but understanding its structure and motion matters for any future deflection strategy.

The three missions turned asteroids from points of light into known landscapes. They showed that many near-Earth objects are loose rubble piles, that the most common primitive material is underrepresented among meteorites, and that water and organic chemistry were active in the outer Solar System within a few million years of the Sun's birth.

More samples are coming. China's Tianwen-2 is targeting asteroid Kamo'oalewa for return in 2027. Japan's MMX mission aims to bring back material from Phobos in 2031. Hayabusa2 and OSIRIS-REx are continuing to other asteroids. Each new capsule adds a page to a story that began 4.6 billion years ago—and that now sits, in part, on laboratory benches on Earth.