The Brightest Gamma-Ray Burst May Have Revealed Radioactive Nickel in a Relativistic Jet

On October 9, 2022, the most luminous gamma-ray burst ever recorded was detected by multiple spacecraft. GRB 221009A was so bright that Fermi's main NaI detectors were saturated during the peak, and analyses leaned on other data, including GECAM-C, Swift, Konus-Wind, and Insight-HXMT; Fermi's BGO detectors became usable later.

Months later, the James Webb Space Telescope found spectra consistent with a broad-lined Type Ic supernova, the kind of explosion expected when a massive star's core collapses and launches a relativistic jet. Now, in a preprint posted to arXiv, Rahim Moradi and colleagues propose that a strange emission line seen during the burst's prompt phase could come from radioactive nickel synthesized in that explosion and entrained in the jet.

A line that drifted from 37 to 6 MeV

During the prompt phase, earlier work found a narrow emission line whose central energy drifted downward from about 37 MeV to about 6 MeV. That is extraordinary. The underlying spectrum is modeled as a broad, smooth continuum, so a narrow line points to a specific nuclear or particle process. Proposed explanations have included pair annihilation in the jet, excited high-Z ions, and neutron capture.

The paper offers a different possibility: the line could be the Doppler-boosted version of a 158 keV gamma ray from the decay of nickel-56. A keV is a thousand electron volts, and an MeV is a million electron volts; this is the energy range of nuclear gamma rays. Doppler boosting occurs when a source moves toward the observer at nearly the speed of light, shifting photons to higher energies and intensifying them.

Why radioactive nickel in a jet?

Long gamma-ray bursts are thought to begin in a collapsar: a rapidly rotating massive star collapses to a black hole surrounded by a hot accretion disk. Neutrino annihilation or magnetic processes launched by the accretion flow can drive relativistic jets through the stellar envelope. In the disk, temperatures above a billion kelvin enable nuclear reactions that can forge nickel-56. Disk winds and instabilities can mix that material into the jet and surrounding cocoon. Nickel-56 decays to cobalt-56 with a half-life of about 6.1 days. One decay branch emits a 158 keV gamma ray in 98.8 percent of decays.

If some of that nickel is entrained in the jet, the 158 keV line can be boosted into the MeV range. As the jet's Doppler factor changes with time, the observed line energy slides. The authors say this is consistent with the drift from 37 to 6 MeV.

The 12 MeV line and a faint 24 MeV echo

At 290 to 300 seconds after the trigger, the team analyzed Fermi/GBM spectra from the NaI7 and BGO1 detectors. They fitted the smooth continuum with a Band function—a standard mathematical shape for GRB spectra—and found two Gaussian line components: one at 12.22 ± 0.03 MeV and a second at 24.24 ± 0.12 MeV. The 12 MeV feature is a snapshot of the already known evolving line.

The 24 MeV excess is new and tentative. A likelihood-ratio test gives a difference of 8.93 in the fit statistic, which translates to roughly 1.9 sigma to 3.0 sigma—standard deviations, a measure of statistical significance—depending on the statistical treatment. A Bayesian model comparison favors two lines over one by a Bayes factor of about 10, a likelihood ratio that the authors call moderate, not decisive, evidence. If real, the 24 MeV feature is consistent with the boosted 270 keV decay branch of nickel-56.

A 16 percent mismatch that may be a clue

The two line energies have a ratio of 24.24 to 12.22, about 1.98. In the laboratory, the 270 keV and 158 keV nickel lines have a ratio of about 1.71. The observed ratio is about 16 percent high. The authors argue this is not a fatal flaw. Because the higher-energy 270 keV photons scatter less efficiently off electrons, they may decouple from the outflow at a smaller radius, where the jet is moving faster or has a different angle to the line of sight. That would give them a slightly larger Doppler boost. The same energy-dependent opacity helps explain why higher-energy nickel lines, including a 1562 keV branch, are not seen: they are likely destroyed by gamma-gamma pair production with prompt photons before they escape.

What the nickel model asks of the jet

Using the measured line energy and luminosity evolution, the team derives power laws: the line energy falls as time since 243 seconds to the minus 0.70 power, and the luminosity falls as time since 243 seconds to the minus 1.01 power. In the standard on-axis approximation, that implies the Doppler factor and effective Lorentz factor decline with the same power-law index. The Lorentz factor is a measure of how close the jet's bulk speed is to the speed of light.

The authors then connect the luminosity to the amount of nickel in the jet. Assuming a jet half-opening angle of about 0.03 radians, a radiative efficiency of 0.2 percent, and a nickel mass fraction of 40 percent, they estimate roughly 5.5 × 10^-3 solar masses of nickel entrained in the jet, with a total jet mass of about 1.4 × 10^-2 solar masses. These are not direct measurements; they depend on assumptions about geometry, efficiency, nickel fraction, and how the radiating material is distributed.

Two reservoirs of stellar ash

The JWST supernova analysis pointed to about 0.09 solar masses of nickel in the slow-moving ejecta seen roughly 170 days after the burst. The prompt line, if the model is right, traces a different reservoir: nickel in the fast jet during the first few hundred seconds. The authors caution that these two numbers are not directly comparable. The jet may be locally enriched by disk winds and instabilities, even if the whole ejecta is not uniformly nickel-rich.

Where the case is still open

Caveats are important. The paper is a preprint and has not yet completed peer review. The 24 MeV feature has only moderate significance, and the main conclusion does not depend on it. Fermi/GBM suffered dead time and pulse-pileup during the prompt peak; residual uncertainties in GECAM-C's high-gain channel imply the earliest line fluxes may be overestimated by about 15 to 25 percent, and late-time flux estimates differ between analyses. The inferred nickel mass depends on assumptions about the last-scattering surface—the surface where escaping gamma rays last interact—and on how gamma rays escape the jet. The authors also note that neutrinos from nickel decay would be boosted to about 100 MeV for a jet Lorentz factor near 150, but remain below the sensitivity of current detectors such as Super-Kamiokande and JUNO. Future high-resolution gamma-ray spectrometers could test the idea.

Ashes of a star, accelerated

If the interpretation holds, GRB 221009A did more than break brightness records. It turned a gamma-ray burst into a spectrometer for nuclear ashes, letting astronomers watch fresh nickel ride a relativistic jet away from a dying star. The line's drift would then be a clock and a speedometer at once: a radioactive element, an outflow whose effective Lorentz factor appears to decline, and a supernova's heavy elements all written in the same narrow MeV feature.